Magic Finger Time Detectives

What was happening when ... ?

  • ... the girl saw Mrs Winter?
  • ... the girl pointed her Magic Finger at the Greggs?
  • ... Mr Gregg heard the call of the wild duck?
  • ... Mr Gregg woke up in the morning?
  • ... Mrs Gregg saw Philip and William?
  • ... when the Greggs looked into the house?
  • ... when the Gregg family looked out of the nest?
  • ... when the girl went to the Greggs’ house?

An email to the girl from The Magic Finger

1st paragraph

Say hello and explain what you think about the Girl's actions.

How to start ...

  • Dear Girl with the Magic Finger,
  • Hello! My name is…
  • I am writing to tell you what I think about your magic.
  • I think your actions were…
  • In my opinion, what you did was…
2nd paragraph

Explain why you think this.

  • I think this because…
  • When you changed the Gregg family into birds…
  • I believe this helped/did not help because…
  • For example, in the story…
  • This was fair/unfair because…
  • Another reason is that…
3rd paragraph

Give friendly advice.

  • I would like to give you some advice.
  • Next time, you could…
  • Maybe you should…
  • I think it is better to…
  • You can try to…
4th paragraph

Finish the email politely.

  • Thank you for reading my email.
  • Best wishes,
  • Your friend,
Feelings

angry, sad, upset, happy, worried, kind, sorry, brave

Opinion words

I think ... , I believe ... , In my opinion ... , I agree ... , I disagree ... ,
It was fair ... , It was unfair ...

Linking Words

because, and, but, so, also, first, then, finally

After writing:

  • check your spelling and punctuation,
  • read your partner’s email and give feedback,
  • improve your email before sending it.

Let’s talk about our podcast!

Here is a set of reflection criteria that will help you comment on the quality of your podcast!

  • Did we speak clearly and loudly enough? ... Can listeners understand our voices easily?

I think our speaking was ... because ...

  • Did we explain our ideas about fairness well?

I liked the way we explained our ideas ... because ...

  • Did we give examples from the story and real life?
  • Did we work well together as a team? ... Did everyone participate?

Our team was ... because ...

  • Is our podcast interesting and enjoyable to listen to?

I think listeners will / won't like our podcast because …

What was happening when … ?

 

Understanding debate

What are the different parts in an argumentation?

A claim is your idea.
A reason or argument explains why you think this.
Evidence is an example from the story or real life.

Let’s have a debate!

Is it right to use magic to punish someone?
How to start your argument ...
How to start your counterargument ...
I think…, In my opinion…, I believe… I disagree because…, I don’t think that is fair because…, But…
Give a reason
Give an example
This is because…, The reason is that…, One reason is… For example…, For instance…, In the story…
Show consequence / result
Summarise / conclude
As a result…, This can make someone feel…, That is why… So, we can see that…, In conclusion…, Therefore…
Actions & Consequences Vocabulary
Relate to the story Expressions
punish, reward, change, learn a lesson, feel sorry in the story, the girl thinks…, the Greggs learned…,

the Magic Finger shows…

 

Getting ready for a podcast “What is fair?” – Inspired by The Magic Finger

Introduction (30–40 sec)

Role: 🎤 Host
Speakers: 2 pupils

🎯 Goal

Introduce the podcast topic clearly.

story, animals, people

  • Welcome to our podcast!
  • Today we are talking about fairness.
  • We will talk about what is fair and what is unfair.
  • Our story is The Magic Finger.
  • Let’s begin!

Story Connection (1 min)

Role: 📖 Story Expert
Speakers: 5–6 pupils

🎯 Goal

Explain what happens in the story and connect it to fairness.

A. Hunting animals: hunt, animals, hurt, kill, sad, unfair

  • In the story, the Gregg family hunts animals.
  • The girl does not like hunting.
  • She thinks it is unfair to animals.

B. The Magic Finger punishment : magic, change, wings, birds, understand

  • The girl uses the Magic Finger.
  • The Gregg family changes into birds.
  • Now they understand how animals feel.

C. Living in the nest: tree, rain, cold, storm, scared

  • The family must live in a nest.
  • They feel scared and cold.
  • Life is very difficult.

D. The ducks with the guns: danger, scared, surprised, lesson

  • The ducks point guns at the Greggs.
  • Mr Gregg feels scared.
  • Now he understands how animals feel.

E. The family changes: promise, change, kind, help, birds

  • Mr Gregg promises to stop hunting.
  • The family breaks their guns.
  • They start feeding birds.

Real-Life Examples (1–2 min)

Role: 🌍 Real-Life Expert
Speakers: 5 pupils

🎯 Goal

Connect the idea of fairness to real life.

A. Fairness at school
  • At school, it is fair when…
  • It is unfair when…
B. Fairness to animals
  • Animals should be treated kindly.
  • It is fair when people protect animals.
  • It is unfair when people hurt animals.
C. Fairness at home
  • At home, it is fair when…
  • Everyone helps.
  • Everyone shares.
E. Fairness in games
  • Games are fair when…
  • Everyone follows the rules.
  • Everyone has a chance to play.

Different Opinions (1 min)

Role: 💭 Opinion Speaker
Speakers: 2–3 pupils

🎯 Goal

Show that people may think differently.

opinion, agree, disagree, fair, unfair, animals, punishment

  • Some people think hunting is OK.
  • Others think it is wrong.
  • Some people believe the punishment was fair.
  • Others believe it was too strong.
  • We think…
  • We agree/disagree because…

Conclusion (30 sec)

Role: 🎤 Host / Summary Team
Speakers: 3 pupils

🎯 Goal

Summarise what was learned.

  • So, what is fairness?
  • Fairness means being kind and respectful.
  • We learned that our actions affect others.
  • The story teaches us to care for animals.
  • Thank you for listening!

Vocabulary revision crosswords!


Lessons learnt from The Magic Finger: Is it right to use magic to punish someone?

We are getting ready for an exciting debate about The Magic Finger. The question we will discuss is:

“Is it right to use magic to punish someone?”

Now it’s your turn to share your ideas!

  • Think about the story: Why did the girl use her magic finger?
  • Think about real life: How should we react when someone does something wrong?
  • Give reasons and examples to support your opinion.

Click the link below to add your arguments, vote for ideas, or reply to other students’ thoughts:

https://www.kialo-edu.com/p/43f9a026-659d-4eb7-87ae-02e847327f19/640244

 

Let’s talk about the characters

Follow the link to match the character traits with their definitions and with the characters in The Magic Finger!

https://app.wizer.me/learn/G5JLTV



You can also practise character traits here!

Now, choose two adjectives to describe a character and explain why in a comment!

Example: The girl is brave because she speaks up.